Check explainer · v1

Titles and H1s across the site: missing and duplicated

Automated

Last reviewed

One missing H1 is a page problem; two pages sharing a title is a template problem. This rule reads the whole crawl matrix for both.

How this check works

Across every analyzed page: a missing <h1> fails, and a missing <title> fails on crawl-only pages (missing titles on pages in the audit list are graded by the page-level title rule instead, so nothing double-reports). Identical titles shared by two or more pages, and identical H1s shared by two or more pages, are flagged as duplicates that name the other URLs.

What does a failure look like?

A theme renders the H1 only on posts while pages ship without one; a template variable left unset makes twenty product titles identical; category pages that all print the site name as their H1 — the matrix turns each into a group with its members named.

How to fix it, step by step

  1. Give every template a real title element and exactly one H1 that carries the page’s own subject.
  2. Rewrite the duplicated groups so each page describes itself, not the template.
  3. Re-run the crawl and confirm the duplicate groups dissolve into per-page values.

What does a pass or fail look like?

Good

No missing titles or H1s; every title and H1 unique across 37 pages.

Fail

Eight category pages share the H1 “Our products” — the finding names all eight so the template fix is obvious.

Frequently asked questions

Why do duplicates matter more than length here?

This rule reads the whole site, so it catches the template-level failure: pages that cannot be told apart. Length and truncation are graded per page by the snippet rules; uniqueness is a site-structure question.

Does an exact match count as duplicate?

Yes — after whitespace trimming, two pages whose titles or H1s are character-for-character identical land in the same group. Near-duplicates of body text are a separate rule.

Is a missing H1 on one page still a fail?

Yes. The crawl grades every analyzed page for both elements; only missing titles are delegated to the page-level rule when the page is in the audit list, to avoid the same defect reported twice.

This rule is one of the checks the audit runs. Run the full site audit

Free preview; no account needed.

Visdenda check explainers · one page per published ruleTitles and H1s · v1