Check explainer · v1
Paywalled content markup: mark the section, not the page
Last reviewed
A subscription page can still be indexed. The markup’s job is to name the gated section precisely — a page-level flag without section markers hides the wrong thing.
How this check works
Only declared paywalls are judged: an Article, NewsArticle, BlogPosting, WebPage or CreativeWork node that declares isAccessibleForFree. A value of false marks the page as gated; the audit warns when hasPart section markers are missing or an entry has no cssSelector. Pages that never declare the property are not judged; a declaration of true passes.
What does a failure look like?
A paywalled article flips isAccessibleForFree to false but ships no hasPart list; the hasPart entries exist yet carry no cssSelector; a redesign drops the section markers while the flag stays — Google knows the page is gated but not what is gated.
How to fix it, step by step
- Declare isAccessibleForFree: false on the node that covers the gated content.
- Add one hasPart entry per gated section, each with a cssSelector that matches the element on the page.
- Keep the selectors current through redesigns — the audit proves the field is present, not that the selector still matches.
What does a pass or fail look like?
Good
A NewsArticle declares isAccessibleForFree: false with two hasPart entries, each carrying a cssSelector.
Fail
The flag says the article is paywalled, but hasPart is missing — the finding is a warning because the gated section is unnamed.
Frequently asked questions
Why is an incomplete marker a warning, not a failure?
Because the page is already declared as gated; what is missing is the precision about which section. The audit treats the section markers as a recommendation, not a hard requirement, and keeps the severity honest.
Does every article need paywall markup?
No. Only pages that actually gate content should declare it. A free article with no declaration is not judged; adding isAccessibleForFree: false to a page that is free is the real mistake.
Should the whole page be hidden from search?
No. The goal is to keep the page indexable while marking the gated section, so a preview can still appear. Hiding the entire page with noindex removes it from results instead of describing it.
This rule is one of the checks the audit runs. Run the full site audit
Free preview; no account needed.