Check explainer · v1

Soft 404: when a 200 page is really a missing page

Automated

Last reviewed

A soft 404 is a URL that answers 200 while showing a missing-page experience. Users hit a dead end and crawlers index nothing — the check grades how convincing each 200 page is.

How this check works

The page’s title and H1 are scanned for 404 markers — 404, not found and their equivalents. A flagged page is then graded by how much real text it renders: a near-empty body (under 200 visible characters) fails, 200–499 characters is a suspect worth a human look, and 500 or more passes.

What does a failure look like?

Search facets emitting empty “no results” screens at 200; discontinued products served from a “page not found” template with the 200 status left on; CMS pagination past the last real page rendering the theme’s 404 block — the status code promises content the page does not deliver.

How to fix it, step by step

  1. Return a real 404 or 410 status for URLs that have no content — the status code, not the message, is what crawlers trust.
  2. Give thin result states real content: featured products, editorial picks, or a noindex on genuinely empty facets.
  3. Re-check the flagged URLs after the template change and confirm the 404 marker and the near-empty body are gone.

What does a pass or fail look like?

Good

Every 200 page renders 500+ characters of real content; true missing pages return a 404 status.

Fail

“/collections/last-page” returns 200 with “Page not found” as the H1 and a 90-character body — a soft 404 in Search Console’s words.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Google report Soft 404 if the URL returns 200?

Google fetched the page, saw a missing-page experience on a success status, and classified the URL as Soft 404 under Page indexing. When the status code and the rendered content disagree, search engines trust the content.

Is a soft 404 the same as a 404?

No. A 404 is a status the server declares; a soft 404 is content that contradicts the 200 the server sent. Returning the correct status fixes a real 404; adding real content — or returning the error status honestly — fixes a soft 404.

Do thin pages always count as soft 404s?

No. The audit only flags pages whose title or H1 carries a 404 marker. A short but genuine page without markers passes, and a flagged page with 200–499 characters of body is a suspect (warn), not a failure.

This rule is one of the checks the audit runs. Run the full site audit

Free preview; no account needed.

Visdenda check explainers · one page per published ruleSoft 404 · v1